PrecisionFDA
Truth Challenge
Engage and improve DNA test results with our community challenges
Explore HG002 comparison results
Use this interactive explorer to filter all results across submission entries and multiple dimensions.
| Entry | Type | Subtype | Subset | Genotype | F-score | Recall | Precision | Frac_NA | Truth TP | Truth FN | Query TP | Query FP | FP gt | % FP ma | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1601-1650 / 86044 show all | |||||||||||||||
| qzeng-custom | SNP | ti | map_l125_m1_e0 | het | 82.7364 | 72.3585 | 96.5897 | 86.1572 | 13217 | 5049 | 13170 | 465 | 385 | 82.7957 | |
| anovak-vg | SNP | ti | HG002complexvar | homalt | 98.2762 | 97.3918 | 99.1768 | 17.9619 | 188418 | 5046 | 185045 | 1536 | 1381 | 89.9089 | |
| gduggal-bwaplat | SNP | ti | map_l150_m1_e0 | het | 74.1845 | 59.2724 | 99.1222 | 91.2737 | 7332 | 5038 | 7340 | 65 | 21 | 32.3077 | |
| ckim-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e0 | homalt | 72.5580 | 56.9536 | 99.9400 | 81.6478 | 6663 | 5036 | 6663 | 4 | 2 | 50.0000 | |
| jpowers-varprowl | INDEL | I1_5 | * | homalt | 94.7762 | 91.6661 | 98.1046 | 39.3198 | 55392 | 5036 | 55332 | 1069 | 948 | 88.6810 | |
| ckim-isaac | SNP | * | HG002compoundhet | * | 87.4314 | 80.5166 | 95.6453 | 38.0766 | 20791 | 5031 | 21327 | 971 | 803 | 82.6982 | |
| asubramanian-gatk | INDEL | * | * | * | 98.8418 | 98.5404 | 99.1451 | 71.3671 | 339513 | 5029 | 339442 | 2927 | 1779 | 60.7790 | |
| gduggal-bwaplat | SNP | tv | map_l100_m0_e0 | * | 70.5375 | 54.6373 | 99.4907 | 88.8156 | 6056 | 5028 | 6056 | 31 | 10 | 32.2581 | |
| ckim-isaac | SNP | ti | map_l150_m2_e0 | het | 75.7150 | 61.0434 | 99.6704 | 79.9741 | 7863 | 5018 | 7863 | 26 | 2 | 7.6923 | |
| jmaeng-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e0 | homalt | 72.7253 | 57.1502 | 99.9701 | 80.8789 | 6686 | 5013 | 6686 | 2 | 2 | 100.0000 | |
| gduggal-bwaplat | SNP | * | map_l250_m2_e1 | * | 54.2324 | 37.2605 | 99.5985 | 97.3745 | 2976 | 5011 | 2977 | 12 | 3 | 25.0000 | |
| ciseli-custom | SNP | ti | map_l150_m1_e0 | * | 78.8472 | 74.5840 | 83.6274 | 80.0382 | 14702 | 5010 | 14695 | 2877 | 739 | 25.6865 | |
| asubramanian-gatk | SNP | tv | map_l100_m0_e0 | het | 46.8906 | 30.6425 | 99.8196 | 93.3017 | 2213 | 5009 | 2213 | 4 | 1 | 25.0000 | |
| gduggal-snapplat | INDEL | D1_5 | lowcmp_AllRepeats_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | homalt | 82.6699 | 77.1496 | 89.0409 | 77.8450 | 16895 | 5004 | 19914 | 2451 | 1673 | 68.2579 | |
| gduggal-snapplat | INDEL | D16_PLUS | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331 | * | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0 | 4999 | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
| gduggal-snapplat | INDEL | D16_PLUS | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_all_merged | * | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0 | 4999 | 0 | 0 | 0 | |||
| gduggal-snapfb | INDEL | D16_PLUS | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331 | * | 0.0800 | 0.0400 | 100.0000 | 0.0000 | 2 | 4997 | 1 | 0 | 0 | ||
| gduggal-snapfb | INDEL | D16_PLUS | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_all_merged | * | 0.0800 | 0.0400 | 100.0000 | 0.0000 | 2 | 4997 | 1 | 0 | 0 | ||
| astatham-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e1 | * | 91.4615 | 84.4862 | 99.6922 | 80.1245 | 27213 | 4997 | 27207 | 84 | 40 | 47.6190 | |
| egarrison-hhga | SNP | * | * | * | 99.8985 | 99.8365 | 99.9607 | 18.3304 | 3049624 | 4995 | 3049677 | 1199 | 305 | 25.4379 | |
| gduggal-snapvard | SNP | * | HG002compoundhet | * | 79.9672 | 80.6669 | 79.2796 | 52.8107 | 20829 | 4992 | 20864 | 5453 | 2407 | 44.1408 | |
| gduggal-snapvard | INDEL | * | lowcmp_AllRepeats_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | het | 79.4795 | 89.6706 | 71.3684 | 71.4189 | 43284 | 4986 | 93686 | 37585 | 31016 | 82.5223 | |
| qzeng-custom | SNP | tv | map_l100_m2_e1 | * | 88.3100 | 80.2832 | 98.1201 | 78.5916 | 20298 | 4985 | 20251 | 388 | 306 | 78.8660 | |
| ckim-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m1_e0 | homalt | 71.6189 | 55.8059 | 99.9365 | 80.2510 | 6291 | 4982 | 6291 | 4 | 2 | 50.0000 | |
| gduggal-snapplat | INDEL | * | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_TRlt7_51to200bp_gt95identity_merged | * | 24.1770 | 18.1983 | 36.0063 | 77.7972 | 1107 | 4976 | 1374 | 2442 | 776 | 31.7772 | |
| ckim-isaac | SNP | tv | map_l100_m0_e0 | * | 71.0742 | 55.1877 | 99.8043 | 69.9269 | 6117 | 4967 | 6119 | 12 | 3 | 25.0000 | |
| qzeng-custom | SNP | tv | map_l100_m2_e0 | * | 88.2470 | 80.1862 | 98.1096 | 78.5989 | 20073 | 4960 | 20033 | 386 | 305 | 79.0155 | |
| gduggal-bwaplat | SNP | * | map_l250_m2_e0 | * | 54.0835 | 37.1211 | 99.5918 | 97.3661 | 2927 | 4958 | 2928 | 12 | 3 | 25.0000 | |
| jmaeng-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m1_e0 | homalt | 71.8022 | 56.0188 | 99.9683 | 79.3360 | 6315 | 4958 | 6315 | 2 | 2 | 100.0000 | |
| anovak-vg | INDEL | D6_15 | lowcmp_AllRepeats_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | hetalt | 0.0000 | 27.2460 | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 1856 | 4956 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| ckim-vqsr | SNP | * | map_l125_m0_e0 | het | 75.2621 | 60.9365 | 98.3935 | 91.9254 | 7717 | 4947 | 7717 | 126 | 0 | 0.0000 | |
| gduggal-bwaplat | SNP | tv | map_siren | homalt | 83.2538 | 71.3283 | 99.9675 | 62.6549 | 12297 | 4943 | 12293 | 4 | 3 | 75.0000 | |
| qzeng-custom | SNP | tv | map_l100_m1_e0 | * | 88.0506 | 79.8294 | 98.1596 | 77.4096 | 19559 | 4942 | 19521 | 366 | 304 | 83.0601 | |
| gduggal-bwafb | INDEL | * | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_all_gt95identity_merged | * | 91.7140 | 88.5981 | 95.0570 | 53.8425 | 38394 | 4941 | 44230 | 2300 | 2147 | 93.3478 | |
| astatham-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e0 | * | 91.4701 | 84.5033 | 99.6888 | 80.0769 | 26916 | 4936 | 26910 | 84 | 40 | 47.6190 | |
| mlin-fermikit | SNP | * | map_l250_m1_e0 | * | 45.7291 | 31.7641 | 81.6080 | 76.7628 | 2294 | 4928 | 2294 | 517 | 446 | 86.2669 | |
| anovak-vg | INDEL | I1_5 | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_all_gt95identity_merged | * | 49.1325 | 41.4437 | 60.3241 | 51.4691 | 3485 | 4924 | 6068 | 3991 | 3216 | 80.5813 | |
| gduggal-snapvard | INDEL | D6_15 | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_TRlt7_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | * | 60.5607 | 55.5947 | 66.5009 | 43.6531 | 6161 | 4921 | 6019 | 3032 | 2878 | 94.9208 | |
| egarrison-hhga | INDEL | * | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_TRlt7_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | * | 85.2884 | 84.6243 | 85.9630 | 70.3947 | 27073 | 4919 | 27454 | 4483 | 4096 | 91.3674 | |
| eyeh-varpipe | INDEL | * | * | homalt | 92.5348 | 96.0734 | 89.2476 | 55.4307 | 120257 | 4915 | 121109 | 14591 | 14265 | 97.7657 | |
| ciseli-custom | INDEL | I1_5 | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_TRlt7_lt101bp_gt95identity_merged | * | 39.8947 | 28.8609 | 64.5870 | 56.5465 | 1994 | 4915 | 1822 | 999 | 788 | 78.8789 | |
| jmaeng-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e1 | het | 84.9216 | 75.8827 | 96.4049 | 90.5037 | 15452 | 4911 | 15446 | 576 | 40 | 6.9444 | |
| ckim-isaac | SNP | ti | map_l100_m0_e0 | het | 78.6364 | 64.9145 | 99.7144 | 71.0617 | 9077 | 4906 | 9078 | 26 | 3 | 11.5385 | |
| gduggal-bwafb | INDEL | * | * | hetalt | 87.6150 | 80.5643 | 96.0183 | 78.7583 | 20332 | 4905 | 6728 | 279 | 275 | 98.5663 | |
| ckim-gatk | SNP | * | map_l150_m2_e1 | het | 85.0232 | 75.9171 | 96.6114 | 90.2821 | 15459 | 4904 | 15453 | 542 | 42 | 7.7491 | |
| anovak-vg | INDEL | * | lowcmp_Human_Full_Genome_TRDB_hg19_150331_all_gt95identity_merged | homalt | 60.5878 | 57.3058 | 64.2686 | 55.8452 | 6581 | 4903 | 7763 | 4316 | 3401 | 78.7998 | |
| jpowers-varprowl | INDEL | D1_5 | lowcmp_AllRepeats_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | homalt | 85.9015 | 77.6154 | 96.1682 | 66.3211 | 16997 | 4902 | 16966 | 676 | 597 | 88.3136 | |
| ghariani-varprowl | INDEL | D1_5 | lowcmp_AllRepeats_lt51bp_gt95identity_merged | homalt | 85.8608 | 77.6154 | 96.0663 | 66.4017 | 16997 | 4902 | 16973 | 695 | 593 | 85.3237 | |
| qzeng-custom | SNP | tv | * | het | 99.3391 | 99.1721 | 99.5067 | 29.7409 | 586805 | 4899 | 585578 | 2903 | 302 | 10.4030 | |
| ckim-isaac | SNP | ti | map_l150_m1_e0 | het | 75.2265 | 60.4123 | 99.6666 | 78.7514 | 7473 | 4897 | 7473 | 25 | 2 | 8.0000 | |